What does it feel like to be Laertes in Hamlet 5.2.324?
What does it feel like to be wrong? In Shakespeare's Hamlet, Claudius had conspired with Laertes to poison Hamlet with a rapier and a chalice of wine. Hamlet apologizes for the death of Polonius: “I shot mine arrow over the house and hurt my brother” - an accident, blaming madness [1]. Laertes sees the queen drink deeply from the poison chalice. Laertes knows she will die. Witnessing her, Laertes hesitates. Kill Hamlet, now? He says in an aside: “yet it is almost against my conscience.” (5.2.324) But he is too committed to the plan, so he goes ahead. What does it feel like to be Laertes in that moment? In her book, “Being Wrong” (2010), award-winning author Kathryn Schulz notes that being wrong often feels exactly like being right. When Laertes goes ahead with the murderous poisoning plan, when the crucifier follows orders and nails Jesus to the cross, when the Nazi starts up the gas chamber, some people are so committed to a false ideology that they don’t realize (as Lae...